Skip to main content

Principles, Precedents & Pragmatism

Three favourite business words that open up lots of discussion.

And so important in running the Accsys business, because they come up every single day, in one way or another.

Principles
Like many businesses, we built up a set of Policies and Procedures, trying to clearly define the principles by which we run our business.   Much as I loved the Nordstrom model (see below), we realised it was necessary.

Then once we started using them every day, we recognised that they were simply guidelines, needed constant updating and were almost impossible to seamlessly implement.

We found that almost everybody believes that the rules are for other people and their circumstances are the exception that proves the rule.

Precedents
In South Africa, the Family Responsibility rule is very clear, and yet we are constantly asked to expand the rule.  We recently had one staff member ask to take 10 years of Family Responsibility in one as he had never used it before.  When HR pointed out that would be setting rather a significant precedent, he became extremely unpleasant.   Of course, he was one of those who used sick leave as a target….

Pragmatism
Our conversations around precedents, principles and pragmatism are usually quite intense, with a fair amount of disagreement.   However, we have come to the conclusion that while we need to stick to our ethical principles, the business has to come first.  

 For example if, as a matter of principle, we don’t want to work with a particular supplier or rehire a former employee, but it makes business sense, we need to make the pragmatic decision and ensure we have laid down firm ground rules formally.

Forecasting the Future
We also try and look at all possible future results of setting a precedent.  Scenario planning 101.  Then we go ahead, and find there was at least one outcome we hadn’t thought of.   So now we are pragmatic about that, too, and have made it clear to all that just because we do something a particular way once, we do not need to do it the same way a second time, if it damages the business or if it doesn’t make sense, any more.

Adult to Adult
It is challenging to explain that the decision you made 5 years ago was pragmatic, and yes, it might look like a precedent was set, but the circumstances were unusual, and your principles weren’t compromised, then, but you still aren’t prepared to make the same decision now!!!!!

This is when adult to adult conversations need to take place in a really calm way.   Maybe compromises can be reached, but it is critical to business success that you are not forced to repeat mistakes because some time in the past a precedent was set…..

Nordstrom Model
This is the model to which all companies should aspire, in my opinion, however even Nordstrom has moved to more rules!
Welcome to Nordstrom
We’re glad to have you with our Company. Our number one goal is to provide outstanding customer service. Set both your personal and professional goals high. We have great confidence in your ability to achieve them.
Nordstrom Rules: Rule #1: Use best judgment in all situations. There will be no additional rules.
Please feel free to ask your department manager, store manager, or division general manager any question at any time.

Links and References
email:      tschroenn@accsys.co.za
twitter:   @TerylSchroenn

Note
Thank you for reading Teryl@Work.   Should you wish to use any of the material, please acknowledge this blog as the source


Popular posts from this blog

Resignation - keep building relationships

Resignation – avoid burning those bridges It has been a great pleasure working with a colleague like you. Now, you are off to your next big challenge! Good luck and farewell!
Isn’t that what we all want to hear when we leave?  We were appreciated and we will be missed.
The need for all parties to maintain professional conduct in the event of resignation is critical, particularly now when we are working within an unsettled socio-economic climate. Employees should avoid damaging relationships, and employers need to adopt a neutral approach and ensure that there are policies and processes that enable the separation to be objectively handled.  For example: ·A formal resignation letter is required·A formal acceptance of resignation is issued confirming any special conditions·An exit interview takes place·Handovers are planned and executed
Our HR team advise those who resign their position to adhere to a few golden rules. Failure to do so could harm whatever bonds have been formed at the workpla…

It's Not Your Fault, But..

It’s Not Your Fault, But…
Its’s not mine, either. When something goes wrong, whether at work or home, most people immediately start casting around for somebody to blame. Over the weekend, I was reading and drinking a cup of coffee which was perched on the arm of the couch.  I do this daily, and have never spilled it.   My daughter came into the room, I put my reader down next to me and we started chatting.  A little later, I picked the reader up, turned to my coffee, and knocked it over.  Something in my expression caused her to ask whether it was her fault.  Of course, it wasn’t, but a mean, small part of me was thinking, well, no, but if you hadn’t come in the room…  And she was kind enough to help me clear it up!
If that lamp post wasn’t there If that faster person wasn’t in the race If the traffic light hadn’t turned red at just that moment If we hadn’t hired Joe, I would have got the promotion If, if, if….. We are very quick to accept the “if” when it is about us, and much slower to do so…

It's Not My Job

It’s Not My Job
Assuming that there are reasons for saying this: 1.It’s not your job and is totally is outside of your skill set 2.It’s not in your KPIs and you don’t want to do it 3.You believe you are being exploited and want to draw a line as to what you will and won’t do. Outside your skill set This is reasonable and there could be many scenarios where this is appropriate
·Where there is a safety or special licence requirement to do the job eg driving a forklift truck
·Where there is a formal qualification like giving legal advice
·Where additional qualifications are required as in a medical doctor without surgical qualifications or experience


Not in my KPIs This response could be perceived as a lot more negative, not to mention career limiting. If there is a good reason why you can’t step outside your pure job description, share that immediately.  ·“I would love to be able to help, however, I need to complete this project by 5 pm today and I am out of the office all day tomorrow at our larg…